Friday, August 29, 2008

Full-Day Kindergarten??

(post by Marissa) If you don't know I have a small obsession with education and learning; especially when it comes to my future children's education. When I was growing up, I went to kindergarten in the afternoon. I stayed at home in the morning and went to kindergarten in the afternoon. You had the option of morning/afternoon/full day. I don't know anyone that did full day because all of my friend's moms stayed home. When I think about it, I am actually surprised because in a place like NJ, I did not have 1 close friend where their mom worked....Anyways, now it seems like every school is full day kindergarten. And it is not for the kids; it's for the parents. I was speaking with a co-worker and she was saying that after lunch, they just have a nap and a snack. This kind of annoyed me because we always had a snack when we got home and that is when my mom would catch up with us. We certainly weren't just going to sit at the table at the age of 5 and tell her how our day went; but because we needed a snack we sat there and talked with her. Well if they already have a snack, then there is no need to talk to mom about their day! We did not go to daycare or 2 years of pre-school etc, however; I would consider most of the kids in my family fairly intelligent and successful. However, there are def. some late bloomers in my family. Rarely were the bird kids the first to read, etc. However, within a few short years we had passed all the kids that seemed so smart at a young age because while we didn't know some things, we had stronger brains from more positive learning environment in the home. We played a lot and had good discussions with other siblings/parents, etc; which allowed us to pass the other kids. This article below discusses this exact thing. That while a full day kindergarten may put the kid ahead for that 1 year; the effects do not last long and are usually passed by other children. So, it doesn't matter if your kid can read at 4 or 5. What really matters is the strength of the brain and surprisingly a lot of that can be developed from healthy interaction and playing with your children. Children have to use their brain a lot when they play! When I am looking at schools, I hope I can find one that gives my child a half day kindergarten even if some think he/she will be behind for 1 year...he/she will pass the others in time. I mean they are all going to learn how to read and learn those basic math skills. If I teach them 1 on 1, I can teach them the same amount in about 1 hour when it would take the teacher about 2 or 3 hours. If they are at school all day, then the last thing they are going to want to do with me is learn for another hour. Also, when playing and talking with them, you can throw in a lot of teaching in a more fun/interesting way. I think at that young age there are a lot more ways to teach children than just in a formal classroom, you can get their brain thinking and working in lots of ways. I think they will develop their brain more, enjoy learning more, and be smarter if they are developing their brain in more unique ways than just sitting in a classroom. In fact the most expensive schools, Montessori schools practice this form of learning. For whatever reason I have a small passion for this..maybe I'll get on a school board when I have kids or at least the PTA :)

As a sidenote it was kind of easy for my mom because I had several siblings to play and interact with. So I learned a lot from my older siblings. Also, I did go to pre-school at Tomorrow's World and loved it. I am not advocating pre-school at home or home school, but full day kindergarten is not really necessary....And I believe in the option for morning/afternoon/full day. Who knows maybe with hte first full day kindergarted would be good because they may get bored at home with just younger siblings....I just like options :)

http://health.msn.com/kids-health/articlepage.aspx?cp-documentid=100213884&GT1=31036

10 comments:

Ashlynn {mamabear} said...

Interesting - I have never heard that before, thanks for sharing.

The Boyles said...

Hey so I had to comment on this because I have similar feelings to you and Jordan just started all day Kindergarten here in Nebraska -
I really don't think there is an option here and I really had a hard time with that. They don't have nap time here, but they do have snack time and it is hard for me to get him to talk a-lot about his day when he gets home. On the plus side though- he needs the socialization. We are in a unique situation with him having no other siblings at home and so I think in our case he needs to have that time with other kids - but I sure miss him here and wish he wasn't gone so long!

McKenzie Larson said...

That's interesting to think about..last year Will's kindergarten was from 8am-1:40pm, so a little more than half-day. But they didn't have a nap time or anything like that, just always learning. I definitely agree with you though, that having the option would be nice!!

Matt and Dionne said...

We have 1/2 day kindergarten here in UT and I'm glad about it. Lexi will start afternoons from 12:30 to 3:30pm on Tuesday. I didn't put Lexi in Preschool b/c I felt like I could teach her better for free and that the quality time I got to spend with her was invaluable. I had to take her to meet her teacher the other day and to have her assessment done. While the teacher was "quizzing" her on stuff, I had to fill out paperwork, including whether or not she had gone to preschool which I marked no. I listened to Lexi answer quickly and correctly everything but her address. I'm not sure why I never thought to teach her that. But anyway, my point is, I think that as long as you are putting forth your best efforts at home and encouraging them, your child will be just as smart maybe even smarter than the other kids.

Anonymous said...

Oh, I could not agree with you more on this! My mom and I were just having this discussion a few days ago. I fel like THE ONLY Person in all of Houston who does not enroll their kids in "school" at the asge of 2 or 3!! Then when I tell people my kids will not be going to preschool...you should see the looks I get. I don't agree with all day Kindergarten either. Sadly, I have yet to find a school in Houston that does 1/2 day. I think it's only in Utah... so I've heard. Anyway, thanks for the post!! I was serioulsy starting to think I was the only one that felt that way! :)

Kat Curtis said...

I agree - full-day is way, WAAAY too long for a poor 5-year old. I wish there was the half-day option here, but alas there's not. Hence the preschool this year. However, I will say that there are things that will be taught at preschool that I can't teach at home, such as not talking all of the time. It's kind of hard to get your child to conceptualize keeping their thoughts in their head without external help! At least for mine... Sigh. It is frustrating to think of it as being full-day only for the sake of a free daycare option. I've already had my rant about that one a bit ago. Not that you can tell from this comment. :) But, it may be better for kids to be in full-day school than in full-day daycare....who knows. I'll let you know what I think about it next year when Bennie's in the K grind.

Marissa said...

I think pre-school is really good because it gets them at least used to listening to someone else, going somewhere, learning some social stuff, etc. It's a nice stepping stone from playing all day! I'll supplement, but I def want my kids to go to preschool. They usually love it too!

Heidi said...

I also remember as a kid going to afternoon Kindergarten and spending my mornings with Wendy and my Mom.
I think it is good for us all to have options and to make good choices.
I don't know for sure what is best, but I do know that my time with Elle now that she is in school is so limited. When she comes home she wants to go play and we have less one on one time.
I can tell you that here the Kindergaten program is very structured and they do not have naps. After snack they go to learning stations where it was a similar environment to Elle's Montessori where each station taught different life skills or math, science, ect. through creative play.
It definately is sad, though, when you see the different home situations. I'm so thankful for the gospel and the importance of families and our time together.

Anonymous said...

I have a guest post up today on the very same issue over at www.wildparenting.com.

MH5 said...

Kya goes to kindergarten from 9-4 (with no nap time) and LOVES it. ...I'm all for teaching kids at home before they go to school, but I'm sure when your child is that age you will see how well that goes over!